Thoughts on opt out of Mother’s day emails
Have you received an opt-out email (or several) for Mother’s day promotions? Brands are now sending a pre-campaign email asking subscribers to opt out of the oncoming email onslaught.
It first started in 2019 and the initial response was positive as Mother’s day can be difficult for many. Like a warning that a series of potentially triggering emails is heading your way so you may want to duck out now.
My initial reaction was also largely positive. Mother’s day campaign messaging can tug on the motherhood heartstrings quite tight. I really miss my Mum on Mother’s day as we live on different continents so I don’t get to see her. I when begin to imagine the emotions for those whose mums have passed away, or are struggling with fertility, or have absent mothers (and a host of other situations). So I can see why this gesture would be appreciated.
Remember us?
However, I had my reservations on the execution from the start. It reminded me of the great GDPR era where companies came out of nowhere asking you to opt in to / opt out of their marketing emails. Some definitely used it to remind subscribers that they still exist, rather than gathering consent!
This is not a promo email but…
I find it superfluous to send a separate announcement email. The opt-out message could have easily been added to the top of the first promo email in the campaign!
Let’s face it, any email about Mother’s Day is going to remind you about the event. Even if it’s an opt-out one. So why send an extra one?
Everyone else is doing it!
This is probably the cynic in me but it does have a hint of virtue-signalling when brands that you wouldn’t typically associate with Mother’s Day campaigns suddenly send an opt-out email.
It’s not once and done
This opt-out email is resent every year which I really don’t get. Yes, circumstances may change for some. But those who would like to permanently opt-out will keep getting the reminders. Those who don’t mind the promo emails will keep getting an extra one each year too!
On one of my now rare visits to mumsnet, I came across the below which gives some perspective to what I’m trying to say here:
I just wanted to ignore it, not have to repeatedly confirm my status as a non-mother with nothing to celebrate
Where does it stop?
So you get an email for Mother’s Day, then Father’s day. What about Christmas? New Year? Easter? If every brand you’ve had an interaction sent an opt-out email for all of these, well, there’d be a lot more unsubscribes than opt-outs!
There must be a better way or two
Like I’ve previously suggested, adding the opt out message prominently at the top of the campaign emails, once they’ve started, would work amazingly. Maybe even consider adding it to all emails in the series
Another great solution would be to have a preferences center where subscribers can indicate which emails they’re interested in. That way, no particular campaign is singled out and they’re more in control. An annual email, not close to any major seasonal promo could be sent to subscribers asking them to update their profile.
What do you think? Love it? Dislike it? Don’t care? Let me know below!
