Should you use multiple audiences to organise your Mailchimp lists?
When you first create a Mailchimp account, you get one audience to store all your contacts. The assumption is that you have one business, one brand so you need one audience. However, it is not so black and white for every business. If you cater for contacts with distinct or your list is growing so much that you need to adapt your messaging to different groups, then you need to organise your Mailchimp list.
The first method that pops into your head may be to create multiple audiences. However, just because you can, doesn’t mean you should.
Here are some reasons why you shouldn’t create multiple audiences for the same brand:
1. Mailchimp contact limit treats each audience separately
Each audience is considerd a seperate entity down to the number of contacts. So if you have a significant overlap of contact information, you’ll get charged twice. E.g Say you have a footwear business and you have different audience based on the brands your ccustomers like. So Steve likes Adidas and is added to the Adidas Audience. But then Steve also likes Nike so he ends up in your Nike audience. Steve now count as two separate contacts.
2. It’s very inefficient for sending common emails
If you want to send out the same newsletter to all your contacts, you have to send it to each audience separately. Continuing with our footwear example, an email about a change in store opening hours is relevant to all audiences. However, you have to send them separately to each audience. You can’t send it to all at once.
3. Contacts may receive duplicate emails
Following on from point 2 above, sending multiple emails could result in contacts in different audiences receiving similar emails twice! Your segmentation strategy needs to be on point to ensure that there is no overlap in emails. YOu don’t want to give people a reason to unsubscribe if you can help it. Speaking of segmentation, see point 4 below.
4. Segmentation across audiences is very tricky to maintain
Audiences don’t naturally share information. So if Sarah is in the Adidas audience and the Nike audience, Mailchimp won’t show that details upfront. You have to set up your own system to track that information, which can prove rather complicated where more than 2 audiences are involved.
What scenarios can you create multiple audiences then?
1. If you have different very different brands
This is the best reason to go for different audiences. If you own an art gallery and a car workshop, those audiences will need different messages, branding and so on. You don’t really care about any overlap as you will be sending different emails to each audience.
2. If you have one brand but very distinct customer profiles
This is a tricky one. For example, if you sell kid’s educational resources. You will two customer groups will likely be parents and schools. Your emails to each group will have different tones. You are unlikely to have much contact overlap too. In this case, you could use multiple audiences, but consider using groups first.
3. If you have one brand but a core membership or offering where email is used for vital communication
If you have an online membership for example, where you send out meeting reminders, course materials and so on. Having them in a separate audience means that if they do unsubscribe from your main audience they can still receive crucial product information. You can also rest assured in the safely that you won’t accidentally email everyone on your list with members-only information.
What’s the verdict?
Essentially, stick to one audience and use groups and/or tags to organise your list. If you need multiple audiences, make sure you have a framework to track duplicates so you can send the right emails ONCE to the right people.
If you need help creating a strategy for one (or multiple audiences) then get in touch. My strategy brain is ready and waiting for a challenge!
