MemberVault announcement – my thoughts on the pricing and audience changes
On February 14th, MemberVault made a massive announcement! The kind that you press send then watch your device ping off the chart. Or you go offline to avoid the notifications! Changes to price plans and their target audience will kick in on April 1st 2022.
Summary of the MemberVault changes
- “Forever Free” plan will no longer exist
- Current tiered paid plans will no longer exist
- From April 1st, only one paid plan for $99/month, unlimited everything
- A new focus on premium customers, not those getting started
Some nuances to points 1 to 3 above.
- You can buy the existing paid plans until the end of March. So free users and those on lower tiers are being encouraged to upgrade soon!
- If you upgrade to a paid plan now, but hit the plan limit after April 1st, you get 30% off upgrade to the $99 plan. No time limit has been mentioned around this.
- The new plan also has annual alternative for. $990.
- The current lifetime plan for $2000 won’t be publicly available from the end of March too. Those currently on a lifetime plan can upgrade to the $2000 if they exceed their current lifetime plan limits.
- Those currently on the free plan can stay on that till the end of June 2022. Then the account becomes read-only. Product members won’t be able to log in either. But the account owner can download the data and setup shop elsewhere.
The news broke via email and in the community FB group. I got the email but didn’t open it. I became aware of it when a client forwarded it on to me with their thoughts.
Before you read on, please know that I started this post in an unfiltered, emotional state. I want to keep it true to me, realistic, reflective but without diminishing anyone. If any part of it causes offence, please let me know and I will address it accordingly.
Community reaction
As you can imagine, the news caused quite a stir. There were 3 clear camps (and more in-between)
- Supporters of the founders (regardless of the details of the announcement)
- Non-supporters of the decision (regardless of the reasons behind it)
- Supporters of the founders but not the details of the decision
There were also a few in the outright nasty camp. More than just letting their feelings out. Surprisingly, those who were in favour of the decisions. There were comments belittling those who couldn’t afford $19. Calling people out for not having a profitable business. Accusing free plan users of being freeloaders. Equating $19 to two cups of coffee (in the poster’s country). And so on.
On the flip side, there were comments about losing trust in MV’s founders. Saying the product isn’t currently worth $99. Insinuating that MV supporters have been brainwashed (due to the volume of positive responses). Calling out the method of the announcement as unsympathetic.
My reaction
I had to read the email several times to take in what it was saying. There were a lot of changes at once. The delivery was matter-of-factly.
My first feeling was shock. All of it was unexpected. All of it at once was too much.
Then I was angry at them and at myself. I had recently made business decisions with MV at the center. Decision-making of this proportion doesn’t come easy to me!
Then I grieved at the loss of something I’d pinned my hopes on.
Then I got bitter and started nitpicking. Was customer service even all that? I rarely need it anyway. Is the product even worth the $99 price tag? Other tools offer more. Is their current customer base not good enough for their new goals?
Then came reflection which led to this quote:
Don’t put your eggs in someone else’s basket
Deeper dive anyone?
The Forever Free plan
A lot of people aren’t happy about its demise. They’d been gradually adding limits to it. First was the cap at 100 members. Then 3 active products. And they were about to introduce storage limits before the announcement.
I’ll be honest, I’m not too fussed about this one. It started off overly generous anyway. I wasn’t sure how it was sustainable. Plus the strain it was putting on customer services.
However, it would have been nice to keep some level of free offering. Even a free trial or a free account for 6 months then it’s deleted.
MV is known for its free plan and for being pocket-friendly. My client base is largely in this bracket too. So the loss of anything free also means a loss of my client base.
Is this selfish? Of course. But when you serve 32K+ users, decisions like these affect more than just the business founders. So just like their business decision is inherently selfish, as it should be, I’m allowed some selfish anger, right?!
Then there’s the term “Forever”. Personally, this part wasn’t handled well. There were attempts to explain away “Forever” as something else. Forever is what it is. I don’t recall seeing any small print at the time of signing up. Taking it away is going against that and should have been addressed as such.
A single, much higher price plan
I bought a lifetime plan so no decisions for me here. Phew! But the $99/month is not attractive to the people I recommend MV to. So whilst I might be safe, I need to find another tool for my clients. This isn’t ideal as I like using the tools I recommend so I deliver tons more value.
I also wonder whether the upgrade setup is a clever, last-ditch attempt to convert free plan users. It’s what I would have done 😀
The new client focus
The last point about their client focus is a biggie. It brings everything together rather nicely. For years their free plan has attracted those dipping their toes into the online course and membership world! They’re no longer looking to serve those people. Their ideal customers will be established business owners who already know what they want and have the money to put behind that. That’ll come with more premium customer service and a user cap of 10K to really serve their audience well.
Premium customers will command premium prices and customer service. The customer service argument is usually lost on me. Probably because I don’t tend to need it much. Being a techy, I can usually find a way so my needs are basic. Fix anything urgent and I’ll work around everything else. As in true British spirit, I’ll complain under my breath in the meantime! Could they offer an add-on for those who need premium customer service?
Then a comment in the group made me wonder whether I am the target market. Right now, I would happily pay $19 for it. $99 definitely not. A few key features would be needed to justify that for me.
Business lessons/reflection
- Buiding a business reliant on someone else’s business comes at a risk
- Have a plan B – whether you are the business owner or the client – think of it like a disaster recovering plan
- An apology is better received at the beginning
- Name your products wisely when it comes to terms like Forever, Lifetime, Unlimited
- Don’t postpone making the right decision for your business
- Trust is hard to build but easy to tear down
- Uncomfortable announcements need to be clear and concise
- Everyone’s situation is different – your $19 may be someone else’s $190
- Pivoting with a large customer base may need some messaging expertise
What next?
It’s taken me two days to digest it all. I’m sticking with MV and trying cheaper platforms to recommend to clients. My husband floated the idea of creating our own platform but I’ve got no desire to handle such a project.
I’ve got a few ideas for a new direction. I might finally have the full confidence to charge my worth! It’ll involve ways to Maximise Your MemberVault and possibly coding some nifty tools to add some advanced functionality. Thankfully MV wasn’t my only offering, but I was about to fully commit to it. So in a way, maybe this was a wake-up call!
I’m also excited about the new features on the roadmap. Like a blog in MV. More ways to get eyes on my products and showcase my expertise! The UI/UX update is what I’m most looking forward to. It’s much needed!
I also want to see what the shift in client base brings and how successful it becomes. I’m especially intrigued by the 10K user cap. Is it a goal they hope to achieve in say 5, 10 years? Or more Like a Big Hairy Audacious number which they’re unlikely to hit?
All in all, they’ve made these decisions for their business. I need to do the same for mine.
Line drawn. Now come check out my MemberVault account.
P.S . Since writing this, I’ve seen a comment that there are over 35K users of MV, of which 32K are on the free plan. That definitely adds more perspective to some of their decision. It’s details like this that would have been handy upfront.
Other nonsensical thoughts
- Was there a reason this was announced on Valentine’s day?
- Why is April 1st the date where most things change?
- Will it all be one big April fool? 😅
